Minutes for 0005: Missing enable for Link Aggregation TLV

Standard: 802.1Q-2011 Clause: D4 and LLDP-EXT-DOT1-V2-MIB.mib Draft with fix: 802.1AX-REV Status: Published
Submitter: Pat Thaler Date: 2011-06-17 Rationale: The Link Aggregation TLV was added to the dot1 LLDP TLVs (moved from dot...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2011-07-18 Jul 2011 Plenary We agree there is a problem and are fairly sure the solution is correct, but would need to combine the changes in the MIB and check the MIB with an expert. Perhaps it could be included in DNRI or 802.1AX, but there are no plans to modify LLDP MIB in these at this point. This also brings up the issue of whether 802.1AX allows LLDP to be sent on the physical link as well as on the aggregate. This should go into the next revision of 802.1AX and DNRI is an ammendment. We may need to consider a revision at a future meeting. Also, the non-LinkAgg issues would not be covered by this proposed course of action. Move to awaiting ballot Ready for Ballot
2011-09-01 Sep 2011 Interim The extension MIB is open in Qbg and we could fix some of the relevant bits, but this is in working group recirc. The best long-term answer solution is to put this in AX, but we don’t have a revision scheduled. Since there is really no new information to change the urgency, we will leave this in its current state. Resolution could be related to 0009 to be discussed in Nanjing Ready for Ballot
2011-11-08 Nov 2011 Plenary Still waiting for a project, but as discussed in 0009, we will be revising the AXbq PAR to be a full revision, so this will get incorporated there. Ready for Ballot
2012-01-11 Jan 2012 Interim AX-Rev PAR has not yet been developed, but will be in Munich. Contributions for this will be entertained once the AX-Rev project is created Ready for Ballot
2012-03-06 Mar 2012 Plenary AX-Rev is in task group ballot. A comment to resolve this has been submitted by Pat Thaler. Subsequent resolution will be handled in the task group Ready for Ballot
2012-07-17 Jul 2012 Plenary This was originally put in on .1AXrev draft01, .1AXrev editor will ensure this comment is included for discussion. Subsequent resolution will be handled in the task group Ready for Ballot
2012-09-12 Sep 2012 Interim 1AXrev editor will ensure this comment is included for discussion. Subsequent resolution will be handled in the .1AXrev task group. Ready for Ballot
2012-11-13 Nov 2012 Planery Resolution will be handled in the .1AXrev task group. Ready for Ballot
2013-01-15 Jan 2013 Interim Resolution will be handled in the .1AXrev task group. Ready for Ballot
2013-03-19 Mar 2013 Plenary Resolution will be handled in the .1AXrev task group. Ready for Ballot

Back