Minutes for 0043: MRPDU transmission actions

Standard: 802.1Q-2011 Clause: Draft with fix: 802.1Q-REV Status: Published
Submitter: Aaron Stewart, Bob Noseworthy Date: 2012-09-06 Rationale: Clause states "MRPDU transmission as a result of the operation ...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2012-09-12 Sep 2012 Interim There appears to be no conflict given the introduction “unless stated otherwise” and the suggested conflict falls into this case. The action definitions are part of the state machine. Mick Seaman will review the MRP set and report back on recommendation Technical experts review
2012-11-13 Nov 2012 Planery Review by Mick Seaman in progress. Technical experts review
2013-01-15 Jan 2013 Interim Agree. The offending (clearly wrong) text about transmitting only if the Port was in a Forwarding state was the result of incorrectly accepting a ballot comment at some stage in the process. It is very clear that if the MAP Context no longer provides connectivity between points A and B and an attribute registration was previously being forwarded from A to B, then the registration has to be explicitly withdrawn by B sending a Leave (or some equivalent action). Include in 802.1Q-REV Ready for Ballot
2013-03-19 Mar 2013 Plenary Q-REV draft prepared. Ready for WG ballot Ready for Ballot
2013-05-15 May 2013 Interim Included in 802.1Q-REV D1.0, in ballot Balloting
2013-07-15 Jul 2013 Plenary 802.1Q-REV D1.2 is balloting Balloting
2013-09-03 Sep 2013 Interim 802.1Q-REV is in WG ballot recirc Balloting
2013-11-12 Nov 2013 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in WG ballot recirc Balloting
2014-01-22 Jan 2014 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot Balloting
2014-03-18 Mar 2014 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot recirc Balloting