Minutes for 0091: VDP state machine variables and parameters

Standard: 802.1Qbg-2012 Clause: 41.5.5 Draft with fix: 802.1Q-REV Submitted: 2013-01-09
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2013-01-15 Jan 2013 Interim Technical review -- discuss on DCB conference call before next meeting Mostly agree, however the proposed solution does not clean up all the loose ends. The MIB variable ecpOperAckTimerInit was originally intended to store the operational exponential value, however this was not conveyed correctly in the SNMP MIB. At very least clause 12 needs to be aligned with the SNMP MIB since clause 12 types this variable “timer exp”. We used units of usec in the MIB for these variables. Also the variable urpVdpResourceWaitDelay I believe was a reference to  urpVdpOperRsrcWaitDelay. This also needs review for alignment between clause 41, 12, 17, and D.2. Technical experts review
2013-03-19 Mar 2013 Plenary The proposed solution does not clean up all the loose ends. It is clear that we used units of usec in the MIB for these variables but it should be state machine ticks of 10 usec. Alignment is needed between clause 41, 43, 12, 17, and D.2. The resolution is described in the slides form this meeting. Paul Bottorff will provide exact changes. Target for 801.Qrev Complete then Ballot
2013-05-15 May 2013 Interim Paul Bottorff provided detailed text for the editor for 91, 93, 107 and others as a part of a ballot comment on 802.1Q-REV D1.0 Editor will include in draft and send for another Task Group ballot for review Target for 801.Q-REV Ready for Ballot
2013-07-15 Jul 2013 Plenary Included in 802.1Q-REV D1.2 that is in balloting Ready for Ballot
2013-09-03 Sep 2013 Interim 802.1Q-REV is in WG ballot recirc Balloting
2013-11-12 Nov 2013 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in WG ballot recirc Balloting
2014-01-22 Jan 2014 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot Balloting
2014-03-18 Mar 2014 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot recirc Balloting
2014-05-14 May 2014 Interim 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot recirc Balloting
2014-07-15 Jul 2014 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot recirc Balloting

Back