Minutes for 0093: ECP State Machine Variables

Standard: 802.1Qbg-2012 Clause: 43.3.7.4, 43.3.4,12.26.1,12.27.1,41.5.5.9,41.5.5.13 Draft with fix: 802.1Q-REV Status: Published
Submitter: Kodirov Nodir and Sung Hyuk Byun Date: 2013-01-09 Rationale: The R field of EVB TLV is the maxRetries value for ECP state machine (43...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2013-01-15 Jan 2013 Interim Technical review -- discuss on DCB conference call before next meeting It seems like converting consistently to Tries is the smaller change rather than converting the state machine and MIB to Retries. The EVB TLV could change to maxTries with a 0 value to 8 tries. Alternately, we could leave the EVB TLV maxRetries and use maxTries internally by adding some statements in D.2. Technical experts review
2013-03-19 Mar 2013 Plenary Agree with resolutions 2-5, but do not change state machine as suggested. Instead simply change the following aspects ackTimer = = 0 && (retries < maxRetries) to ackTimer = = 0 && (retries <= maxRetries) ackTimer = = 0 && (retries = = maxRetries) to ackTimer = = 0 && (retries > maxRetries) Paul Bottorff will provide revised state machine and detailed object changes. Target for 802.1Qrev Complete then Ballot
2013-05-15 May 2013 Interim Paul Bottorff provided detailed state machine and detailed object changes for the editor as a part of a ballot comment on 802.1Q-REV D1.0 Editor will include in draft and send for another Task Group ballot for review Target for 801.Q-REV Ready for Ballot
2013-07-15 Jul 2013 Plenary Included in 802.1Q-REV D1.2 that is in balloting Ready for Ballot
2013-09-03 Sep 2013 Interim 802.1Q-REV is in WG ballot recirc Balloting
2013-11-12 Nov 2013 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in WG ballot recirc Balloting
2014-01-22 Jan 2014 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot Balloting
2014-03-18 Mar 2014 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot recirc Balloting
2014-05-14 May 2014 Interim 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot recirc Balloting
2014-07-15 Jul 2014 Plenary 802.1Q-REV is in sponsor ballot recirc Balloting

Back