Minutes for 0141: Remove 6.6.1 and 6.7.1

Standard: 802.1Q-2014 Clause: 6.6.1, 6.7.1 Draft with fix: 802.1Q-Rev/D1.1 Status: Published
Submitter: John Messenger Date: 2014-07-17 Rationale: Maintenance item 0125 copied these functions from 802.1Q to 802.1AC, but...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2014-07-17 Jul 2014 Plenary Received Received
2014-07-17 Sep 2014 Interim Proposed to fix this in next 802.1Q maintenance document. Complete then Ballot
2014-07-17 Nov 2014 Plenary Proposed to fix this in next 802.1Q maintenance document. Complete then Ballot
2014-07-17 Jan 2015 Interim Proposed to fix this in next 802.1Q maintenance document. Complete then Ballot
2014-07-17 Mar 2015 Plenary Proposed to fix this in next 802.1Q maintenance document. Complete then Ballot
2014-07-17 May 2015 Interim Proposed to fix this in next 802.1Q maintenance document. Complete then Ballot
2014-07-17 Jul 2015 Plenary Proposed to fix this in next 802.1Q maintenance document. Complete then Ballot
2016-11-08 Nov 2016 Plenary Target 802.1Q-Rev. Complete then Ballot
2016-12-15 Jan 2017 Interim In implementing this item, the editor found that the referemce to 6.6.1 in 12.16.1 was an error. Qbg introduced this text and this was a reference to non-existent 6.6.5. Qbg's MIB reveals that by 6.6.5 they meant "EVB Status Parameters" which was really 6.6.6, but that subclause was moved into the body of Q when 6.6 was moved into 802.1AC. It became 40.4, and still is. So, this reference to 6.6.1 has been changed to 40.4. For 6.7.1, only part of the text has been migrated into 802.1AC. Therefore, 6.7.1 has to be retained and modified to refer to 802.1AC. Two further maintenance requests will be required to complete the work: one to incorporate the remaining material into 802.1AC and one to remove it from 802.1Q. See also http://www.ieee802.org/1/private/email2/msg25521.html Balloting
2018-05-22 May 2018 Interim What can be fixed in 802.1Q-2018, has been. There remains material in 802.1Q 6.7.1, which needs to be moved into 802.1AC in the future. Approved

Back