Minutes for 0202: Qbv ConfigChangeError counter incremented incorrectly

Standard: 802.1qbv Clause: 8.6.9.3.1 Draft with fix: Status: Rejected
Submitter: MSR CHANDRASEKHAR Date: 2018-01-08 Rationale: In the List Config state machine (8.6.9.3):: The rules (b) & (c) us...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2018-01-16 16 Jan 2018 Concall Received
2018-01-23 Jan 2018 Interim There is some agreement that this is a bug. Further study is required to ascertain the exact changes to 802.1Q that would be required to fix it completely. Complete then Ballot
2018-03-06 Mar 2018 Plenary This requires expert review in the TSN task group. Technical experts review
2018-05-22 May 2018 Interim This comment was discussed on the April 23 TSN call and discussed in Tongtong's presentation http://www.ieee802.org/1/files/public/docs2018/maint-qbv-comments-wangtt-0418-v02.pdf. In review, the group decided that the standard is correct as written and there is no error. Rejected

Back