Minutes for 0222: ieee802-dot1q-bridge YANG model should add a 'config false' list for dynamically learned VLANs

Standard: 802.1Qcp-2018	Clause: 48.6.3.3	Draft with fix:	Status: Withdrawn
Submitter: William Zhao	Date: 2018-09-25	Rationale: There is a missing list of dynamically learned VLANs in the 'ieee802-dot...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request

Date	Meeting	Text	Status
2018-09-26	6 Nov 2018 Concall	Received	Received
2018-11-05	6 Nov 2018 Concall	Marc Holnes Response: Need to discuss (tentative Reject). I don’t understand why the current vlan list in the YANG module, can not be used to support dynamically learned VLANs (as well). I don’t see a need to define a dynamic-vlan list. When I look at sub-clause 12.10.2 (the managed object clause) there doesn’t appear to be a need for a separate dynamic-vlan list.	Technical experts review
2018-11-06	6 Nov 2018 Concall	It was requested to defer a discussion on this item so technical experts and discuss with the submitter offline. To be re-visited at the Plenary.	Technical experts review
2018-11-14	Nov 2018 Plenary	There was an offline discussion on this item and the submitter agreed to withdraw the comments. An email was sent to the submitter to confirm the withdrawal and the following response was received: "Hi Paul, Yes for item 222. I agreed to withdraw this comment."	Withdrawn

Back