1. Maintenance Items
2. 0221

Minutes for 0221: ieee802-dot1q-bridge YANG model should limit the configured VLAN names to be unique

Standard: 802.1Qcp-2018	Clause: 48.6.3.3	Draft with fix:	Status: Rejected
Submitter: William Zhao	Date: 2018-09-25	Rationale: The names assigned to VLANs should be unique.
Show Request Show Preformatted Request

Date	Meeting	Text	Status
2018-09-26	6 Nov 2018 Concall	Received	Received
2018-11-05	6 Nov 2018 Concall	Marc Holness Response: Accepted.	Technical experts review
2018-11-06	6 Nov 2018 Concall	Considered an enhancement. The lack of the constraint allows users to create erroneous configurations and shoot themselves in the foot (so to speak).	Technical experts review
2018-11-13	Nov 2018 Plenary	Since the item is not a defect the maintenance process does not apply and the request is being rejected. However, as the proposed resolution has merit the submitter is encouraged to raise an amendment PAR using this and other similar items as motivation for the project.	Rejected

Back