Minutes for 0223: Maintenance Request: IEEE8021-SRP-MIB inappropriate SYNTAX for ieee8021SrpStreamDataFramePriority

Standard: IEEE 802.1Q-2018 Clause: 17.7.14 Draft with fix: 802.1Qcw/D0.4 Status: Approved
Submitter: Josef Dorr Date: 2018-12-14 Rationale: The ieee8021SrpStreamTable includes the object ieee8021SrpStreamDataFram...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2019-01-08 Jan 2019 Interim Received Received
2019-01-16 Jan 2019 Interim The item was reviewed prior to the meeting with Craig Gunther – editor of the SRP draft. MIB experts in the meeting agreed that the proposed resolution is correct, and the maintenance item should be accepted and included in the next available vehicle. The proposal is to include the fix in 802.1Qcw. Technical experts review
2019-01-21 Jan 2019 Interim Hello, The issue, which I described in request 0223, can also be found in the NEW StreamPreloadTable of the 802.1Qcc update version of the IEEE8021-SRP-MIB and should be fixed there consistently: Ieee8021SrpStreamPreloadEntry ::= SEQUENCE { ieee8021SrpStreamPreloadId IEEE8021SrpStreamIdValue, ieee8021SrpStreamPreloadDestinationAddress MacAddress, ieee8021SrpStreamPreloadVlanId IEEE8021VlanIndex, ieee8021SrpStreamPreloadTspecMaxFrameSize Unsigned32, ieee8021SrpStreamPreloadTspecMaxIntervalFrames Unsigned32, ieee8021SrpStreamPreloadDataFramePriority IEEE8021PriorityCodePoint, ieee8021SrpStreamPreloadRank EEE8021SrpStreamRankValue } With Best regards Josef Dorr Technical experts review
2019-03-12 Mar 2019 Plenary Agreed with Qcw editor to make fix in next draft Complete then Ballot
2019-05-21 May 2019 Interim It was agreed that the cost of obsoleting the object out weights the benefit so the exception rule specified in IETF RFC 4181 allows us to make the change to the MIB. The comment submitter will provide an updated MIB to the editor of Qcw for inclusion in the next draft for balloting Technical experts review
2019-07-16 Jul 2019 Plenary MIB has been included in D.04. Verify with Josef and Marina the problem has been adressed Balloting
2023-10-17 17 Oct 2023 Concall P802.1Qcw/D2.2 is in pre-publication. Approved

Back