Minutes for 0270: Missing transmission selection algorithm configuration management

Standard: 802.1Q-2018 Clause: 48 Draft with fix: Submitted: 2020-07-07
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2020-07-07 7 Jul 2020 Concall Received Received
2020-07-07 7 Jul 2020 Concall As discussed on the call, there is an independent, but related issue, which is related to the default configuration of a bridge that supports CBS. The text is indicating that if you support CBS you need to deploy specific default configuration from 34.5. It was agreed to open a separate item for this. Regarding the proposed YANG. It was agreed that the missing list should be added. The specific definition of the leaf, whether as a uint32 or an identity will be further discussed in YANGsters next week. Technical experts review
2020-09-15 15 Sep 2020 Concall Offline discussion with Yangsters concluded that we need to decide is the urgency of providing an updated YANG module with the new leaf. This could be done in Q-Rev by putting in a comment on the current open WG ballot. Currently, Qcz has included the definitions of the traffic selection algorithms in dot1q-types.yang. This, however, makes Q-Rev dependent on Qcz, which isn't desirable because it isn't currently an amendment that is scheduled to be rolled in. So, the action would be to pull out the changes to dot1q-types from Qcz and put them into Q-Rev, along with the new leaf. Another option is to include this in Qcz as resolution to the maintenance item. Technical experts review
2020-09-22 22 Sep 2020 Interim The item was reviewed on the call with the editor present. It was agreed to produce a ballot comment against Q-Rev with sufficient detail on how to make the edits. The actual YANG should be generated and reviewed with Yangsters prior to the closing of the Q-Rev 1st WG ballot. Technical experts review
2020-09-29 22 Sep 2020 Interim Updated YANG was reviewed by YANGsters and attached to a PDF contribution that also contains instructions on other required changes. Several lists, figures and embedded text from YANG files and pyang output need to be updated. All instructions are provided at: https://www.ieee802.org/1/files/public/docs2020/yangsters-congdon-maint-0270-changes-0920-v02.pdf Complete then Ballot