Minutes for 0287: Update IEEE Std 802 to reflect withdrawal of IEEE Std 802.1D

Standard: IEEE Std 802 Clause: 2 Draft with fix: 802f/d0.4 Status: Approved
Submitter: Paul Congdon Date: 2020-10-27 Rationale: IEEE Std 802.1D is proposed to be withdrawn. The technical specification...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2020-10-28 29 Oct 2020 Concall Received Received
2020-12-02 2 Dec 2020 Concall This should be included in a revision project of IEEE Std 802. The revision is likely needed to address the EPD/LPD issues as well. Technical experts review
2020-12-16 16 Dec 2020 Concall There is also 802f project which does have scope to address maintenance items. A ballot comment can be made against the first draft of that project. Complete then Ballot
2021-03-09 9 Mar 2021 Plenary A ballot comment against 802f was made to include this maintenance item. After reviewing each item in the maintenance TG, the proposed changes have been updated as follows (NOTE: the original request was also updated to match this to avoid confusion): The following actions are needed: 1. Remove 802.1D in the normative references (clause 2) list and move the footnotes to 802.1Q 2. Remove 802.1D from Figure 1 3. Replace 802.1D with 802.1Q in first sentence of 4. Reword the last sentence of the first paragraph as follows, "IEEE Std 802.1Q adds additional capabilities beyond the MAC Bridge specification including virtual local area networks (VLANs), priorities, and provider bridging, as described in" 5. Replace 802.1D with 802.1Q in last paragraph of 6. Remove "IEEE Std 802.1D and" in first sentence of 7. Remove 802.1D from and change specify to specifies 8. Replace 802.1D with 802.1Q in 8.2.4 9. Remove "IEEE Std 802.1D and" in 8.3 10. Remove 802.1D from the list of informative standards in Annex D Complete then Ballot
2023-05-16 16 May 2023 Interim Solution has been added to 802f Balloting
2023-10-17 17 Oct 2023 Concall P802f is approved by IEEE SA SB for pre-publication. Approved