Minutes for 0312: Stream ID as a Key for YANG lists

Standard: IEEE Std 802.1Qcc-2018 Clause: 46.3 Draft with fix: Status: Complete then Ballot
Submitter: Don Fedyk Date: 2021-02-22 Rationale: A comment on P802.1Qdj was suggested to be a Maintenance item. Comment: ...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2021-03-12 9 Mar 2021 Plenary This item was created to allow P802.1Qdj to implement a fix. The discussion on the topic has occurred in Yangsters and a solution is to be provided in the next draft of Qdj. The preference is to use upper case for MAC addresses. Complete then Ballot
2022-05-10 9 May 2022 Interim The original typedef should be deprecated and a new typedef should be created with an upper case pattern only. See comment #68 from Qdj/d0.2. https://www.ieee802.org/1/files/private/dj-drafts/d0/802-1Qdj-d0-2-dis-v01.pdf. The comment response indicates: ACCEPT IN PRINCIPLE. Add a new typedef stream-id-type-upper to ieee802-dot1q-tsn-types.yang as follows: typedef stream-id-type-upper { type string { pattern '[0-9A-F]{2}(-[0-9A-F]{2}){5}:[0-9A-F]{2}-[0-9A-F]{2}'; } Add a description to the typedef, based on the description of stream-id-type. Complete then Ballot
2023-04-11 11 Apr 2023 Concall It was agreed to reject the comment in Qdj and eliminate that as a vehicle until a resolution has been further discussed in YANGsters. There is also a need to engage 802.3 who uses the IETF format for MAC addresses in their YANG. Simply changing to IETF format for 802.1 is not currently considered a resolution. Technical experts review
2023-07-11 11 Jul 2023 Plenary Discussion to continue in YANGsters, and resolution to ensue. Technical experts review
2023-09-12 12 Sep 2023 Interim No consensus has emerged in YANGsters on how to address differences between IETF and IEEE formatting. Technical experts review
2023-11-14 14 Nov 2023 Plenary This was discussed in P802.1Qdj and the comment was rejected. Rejected
2024-01-23 23 Jan 2024 Interim Discussed further- Will be brought up in YANGsters, and a proper vehicle will be determined when a solution has been agreed on Technical experts review
2024-03-12 12 Mar 2024 Plenary Technical experts in YANGsters agree to adopt the solution identified in the minute from 9 May 2022. The initial vehicle with an initial draft was 802.1Qdj but it did not make it into the final 802.1Qdj draft. We will target 802.1Q-2022Rev for this. Complete then Ballot