Minutes for 0236: 802.1CB-2017 10.4.1.6 frerSeqRcvyHistoryLength min value s/b 1, not 2

Standard: 802-1CB-2017 Clause: 10.4.1.6 Draft with fix: 802.1CBdb/D0.3 Status: Published
Submitter: Craig Gunther Date: 2019-08-07 Rationale: 10.4.1.6 frerSeqRcvyHistoryLength, states the minimumvalue is 2.Second p...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2019-08-20 3 Sep 2019 Concall Received Received
2019-09-03 3 Sep 2019 Concall We ran out of time to review in sufficient detail to approve the proposed resolution, however, with the short amount of review it appears that allowing a minimum value of 1 would be correct since it is stated in the paragraph this option is allowed. It was agreed to revisit this item at the interim to confirm that a minimum value of 1 is allowed. Technical experts review
2019-09-17 Sep 2019 Interim The minimum value is 2 so the text in 7.4.3.4 should be changed to make it clear that the observation is not a valid case. Consider starting the first sentence of the second paragraph off by saying, "Although the minimum value is 2, one can observe...." Complete then Ballot
2019-11-14 Nov 2019 Plenary Solution included in completed TG ballot of D0.3 Balloting
2022-03-07 7 Mar 2022 Plenary IEEE Std 802.1CBdb-2021 published on March 8th, 2022 Published

Back