Minutes for 0340: Misleading details on ATS MaxResidenceTime

Standard: IEEE Std 802.1Q-2022 Clause: Draft with fix: Status: Complete then Ballot
Submitter: Max Turner Date: 2022-06-15 Rationale: The statement "The parameter limits the duration for which frames can re...
Show Request Show Preformatted Request
Date Meeting Text Status
2022-07-12 12 Jul 2022 Plenary The request was a result of comment resolution on P802.1Qdj/d0.3 and agreed to submit to maintenance. All the stake holders were not present to resolve the issue, so it was agreed to include this discussion on a future Maintenance TG electronic meeting Technical experts review
2022-08-09 9 Aug 2022 Concall It was agreed to replace the last sentence in with a sentence that maintains a description of the reason for the parameter, but does not imply that this value is the only reason for limiting a frame residence within a Bridge. The following text was proposed, "The parameter limits the duration for which frames can reside in a Bridge in the sense that <<ATS Eligibility Time Assignment>> will drop the frame prior to being queued (8.6.7)." This text requires further review. The part in <<>> and the clause reference need to be checked. Technical experts review
2022-08-10 9 Aug 2022 Concall Ongoing email exchanges with state holders fine tuned the proposed replacement sentence. The following recommendation is being made, "The parameter limits the duration for which frames can reside in a Bridge in the sense that ATS eligibility time assignment ( immediately discards all frames with an eligibility time further in the future than defined by this parameter. " Technical experts review
2023-05-16 16 May 2023 Interim The TG agreed that sufficient detail has been provided in the contribution for an editor to make the proposed changes. It was agreed that the priority of the change does not warrant making the change as soon as possible, so this request will be held for the next Q-Revision Complete then Ballot